Hester Lilly by Elizabeth Taylor

Originally issued in 1954, Hester Lilly was Elizabeth Taylor’s first volume of stories. (It’s also my first experience of her short fiction.) There are some brilliant stories here, up there with some of the best scenes from her longer works. The titular piece, in particular, encapsulates many of this writer’s key trademarks: her ability to create nuanced characters with real emotional depth; her acute observations of the subtleties of human interactions; and her capacity to elicit the reader’s sympathy for difficult individuals in spite of their inherent flaws. I’ll come back to this story at the end of my review; but first, a few words about the collection itself.

Hester Lilly comprises seventeen stories of varying length, from brief sketches lasting a couple of pages to the novella-sized titular piece which opens the collection. As with other collections I’ve reviewed, I’m not going try to cover every story; instead, I’ll try to focus on a few favourites to give you a flavour of the volume as a whole.

In the aptly titled story Spry Old Character, a lively veteran horse-trader named Harry has no alternative but to move to a Home for the Blind following the death of his sister/carer. An odd-man-out among the genteel residents of the care home, Harry is left feeling lonely, grumpy and neglected, deflated as he is by the patronising ministrations of Matron and the anodyne environment she seems intent on encouraging.

“You’ll have the company of others like you,” his neighbours had told him. This was not so. He found himself in a society, whose existence he had never, in his old egotism, contemplated and whose ways soon lowered his vitality. He had nothing in common with these faded seamstresses; the prophet-like lay-preacher; an old piano-tuner who believed he was the reincarnation of Beethoven; elderly people who had lived more than half a dim life-time in dark drapers’ shops in country towns. Blind they might not have been; for they found their way about the house, its grounds, the village, with pride and confidence. Indoors, they bickered about the wireless; for the ladies liked a nice domestic play and thought some of the variety programmes ‘suggestive’. The racing results were always switched to something different, hastily, before they could contaminate the air. (pp. 84-85)

In time, Harry makes friends with the local bus drivers and conductors who ferry him around the district on a regular basis – if nothing else, it’s a brief respite from the atmosphere of the home. This is a bittersweet story; the central character is at once both comic and tragic.

Swan-Moving is a very different type of story, one that demonstrates an element of range in Taylor’s work. In this piece, a young swan settles in a dirty pond in a rather shabby, neglected village, much to the fascination of the local residents. Somewhat surprisingly, the swan’s presence seems to spark a sense of change in the locality. As the swan blossoms and grows more resplendent, so do the villagers – for the very first time, they come together to spruce up their village, decorating their houses in bright (albeit rather garish) colours in an effort to improve their environment. This is a lovely story with a slightly magical touch, a delightful addition to the collection.

Taylor’s ear for dialogue comes to the fore in Nods & Becks & Wreathed Smiles as a group of women meet up for a gossip at the local tea shop. Naturally, the subjects under discussion are wide-ranging, from the trials of childbirth to the shortage of fish in the local shops to views on Mrs Liddell’s new ring. This is a short sketch, beautifully observed.

Other stories cover a child’s observations of an elderly woman on holiday from the hustle and bustle of London (The Idea of Age); a woman’s memories of her just-deceased mother as she sits by her side in hospital (First Death of Her Life); and the desperate disappointment of schoolboy’s day out with his mother, their individual worlds seemingly poles apart (A Red-Letter Day). What unites these stories, and many others in this excellent collection, is their ability to capture a scene so effectively, thereby giving the reader access to the thoughts and feelings of the central characters.

Where this collection really excels though is in its depiction of domestic stories: the palpable tensions between semi-estranged partners; the unspoken agonies of lifeless marriages; the painful attempts of a mother to outdo her neighbour.

In Gravement Endommagé, one of my favourite stories in the collection, a married couple – Richard and Louise – drive through the war-ravaged countryside in France, the destruction of the buildings around them only serving to mirror the damaged nature of their relationship. They have come to the continent for a holiday, a trip designed to ‘set things to rights’ between them, their petty bickering with one another having descended into more direct animosity. The years of hardship and isolation during the war have brought about a significant change in Louise, making her fearful and edgy. Now that the grand conflict is over, she remains damaged – intolerant, complaining and overly reliant on drink.

Her doctor, advising the holiday, was only conventional in his optimism. If anyone were benefited by it, it would be the children, stopping at home with their grandmother—for a while, out of the arena. What Richard needed was a holiday away from Louise, and what Louise needed was a holiday from herself, from the very thing she must always take along, the dull carapace of her own dissatisfaction, her chronic unsunniness. (p. 114)

Shadows of the World also falls into this category; it offers a brief yet highly effective snapshot of a family, each individual member orbiting in their own semi-isolated world. This is another beautifully observed story, each thread coming together to form a broader whole.

The star of the show is undoubtedly Hester Lilly, the longest story in the collection at 78 pages. In this piece, a middle-aged woman, Muriel, is dismayed at the prospect of the arrival of her husband’s cousin, a young lady by the name of Hester Lilly. Having been married to Robert for some years, Muriel now feels uncertain of her position in the relationship, and so she imagines Hester, with her undoubted youth and potential beauty, to be a significant threat. However, on Hester’s arrival at the boarding school where Robert works, Muriel fears are initially laid to rest; Hester is gauche, nervous and poorly dressed, every garment appearing to be either too small or too big for her frame.

Nevertheless, it is not long before Muriel realises that she must be on her guard against Hester. With this in mind, she decides upon a pre-emptive strike, casually dropping the following remark into a conversation with her charge: “Of course, you are in love with Robert.” Better to unnerve Hester by tackling the issue head-on before the girl gets a chance to develop any such notions of her own.

Muriel insinuated the idea into the girl’s head, thinking that such an idea would come sooner or later and came better from her, inseparable from the very beginning with shame and confusion. She struck, with that stunning remark, at the right time. For the first week or so Hester was tense with the desire to please, anxiety that she might not earn her keep. Robert would often find her bowed in misery over indecipherable shorthand, or would hear her rip pages out of the typewriter and begin again. The waste-paper basket was usually crammed-fill of spoilt stationary. Once, he discovered her in tears and, half-way across the room to comfort her, wariness overtook him. He walked instead to the window and spoke with his back to her, which seemed to him the only alternative to embracing her. (pp. 8-9)

A little later, Muriel tries to consolidate her position with the following comments, whereby she stresses the triviality of young love and its differentiation from a deeper, more lasting relationship.

“Robert? Oh, yes! Don’t fuss, dear girl. At your age on has to be in love with someone, and Robert does very well for the time being. Perhaps at every age one has to be in love with someone, but when one is young it is difficult to decide whom. Later one becomes more stable. I fell in love with all sorts of unsuitable people—very worrying for one’s mother. But by the time I met Robert I was old enough to be sure that that would last. And it has,” she added quietly; and she chose a strand of white silk and began work on the high-lights of a rose petal. (pp. 13-14)

I suspect some readers might find Muriel a rather cruel and pathetic woman, eaten up with jealousy over the more vulnerable Hester. While I recognise these flaws in Muriel’s character, I couldn’t help but feel a degree of sympathy for her too. She is desperately isolated in her marriage to Robert, a rather cold man who has long revealed himself to be a stranger to her. He no longer displays any tenderness or affection towards Muriel, a fact that is only exacerbated when she finds herself drawn into a compromising position with one of the schoolmasters at a local dance.

This is a terrific story that will test your responses to each of the individual characters. There is also another player in the mix, a desperately sad old woman, Mrs Despenser, who tries to befriend Hester when she goes out for a walk one night. Mrs D is a hangover from a bygone age, a lonely individual living in abject squalor in a dilapidated cottage with only her cat for company. She is desperate for Hester to stay a little while to alleviate her loneliness.

All in all, this is a fine collection of stories, an excellent introduction to Taylor’s short fiction. While a couple of the shorter pieces didn’t quite fly for me, they were never less than well observed. A fairly minor point considering the high quality of the other stories here.

Hester Lilly is published by Virago; personal copy.

36 thoughts on “Hester Lilly by Elizabeth Taylor

  1. Brian Joseph

    I keep saying that I really need to read Elizabeth Taylor. Based on what I read about her she seems like a skilled creator of characters and plot. Flawed characters like Muriel are fine with me.

    These stories sound very good, but I will probably start with one of her novels.

    1. JacquiWine Post author

      If there were one writer I would recommend to you it would be Elizabeth Taylor. She is such a wonderful observer of the dynamics between different characters however flawed or compromised they may be. I think you would like her a lot. The novels are the place to start for sure. Maybe Mrs Palfrey at the Claremont or At Mrs Lippincote’s, but they’re all good. I loved A Game of Hide and Seek too, but it might be worth saving that for later as it’s a little more subtle than some of her other novels.

  2. kaggsysbookishramblings

    Lovely review as always, Jacqui. I’ve read to read Taylor’s shorter works, though I have read all the novels and own the collected stories. She’s so good on the nuances of relationships and also on the horrors of everyday life!

    1. JacquiWine Post author

      Thanks, Karen. Yes, the subtleties really come through. I think you’ll enjoy the stories whenever you get a chance to try them – there are so many to choose from.

    1. JacquiWine Post author

      The titular story — Hester Lilly — might be of interest to you as it’s quite long, almost a novella in fact. Otherwise, I doubt whether this collection is for you given your feelings about short stories.

  3. heavenali

    It’s ages since I read these stories but I remember thoroughly enjoying them. I especially liked the title story which shows such good Character development. Swan moving was such an usual story but one I found oddly moving. I think these stories show Taylor at her best. Fabulous review.

    1. JacquiWine Post author

      Thanks, Ali. Yes, one of the things I liked about this collection was the element of diversity across the range of stories. Some (Hester Lilly, for example) were very much in keeping with Taylor’s novels while others (Swan Moving, in particular) were more unusual, almost as if she was trying out a few different styles or themes to see which elements worked best. I guess that’s one of the advantages of short stories, that ability to experiment a little here and there. And I’m with you on Swan Moving, an oddly touching little tale.

  4. Guy Savage

    I experienced a moment of panic there when I saw the title of the book. It was an Elizabeth Taylor book I didn’t own. Then I saw that it was short stories. I bought the NYRB of ET stories and haven’t got to it yet, and I’m not sure how many of the stories are crossovers into your collection.

    1. JacquiWine Post author

      Ha! Hester Lilly does sound like a title for a novel, a character study of some sort (which it is, albeit in miniature). It’s a great story/novella, beautifully observed – I’m pretty sure you’d like it a lot.

      I have that NYRB collection as well, such a thing of beauty with that gorgeous cover. It’s not close to hand right now, so I’ll have to come back to you on the overlap between the two collections. Hopefully Hester Lilly will be there as it’s a real gem, up there with the best of her writing I think.

  5. Tredynas Days

    I devoured the Collected Stories recently & agree with you: she’s great. Even in the lesser stories (I don’t think she really gets the working classes) she’s always interesting. One theme I noticed is loneliness- which of course features in the novels too- often within relationships as you show – inert marriages or siblings and parents failing to connect. And H Lilly is a triumph. Muriel & the lecherous teacher reveal so much about her conflicted natrue.

    1. JacquiWine Post author

      I’m so glad to hear that you enjoyed Taylor’s stories so much – that’s great. At her best, she’s pretty unbeatable especially when it comes to the subtleties of relationships. I think you’re right about those gulfs between different family members, be they disconnects between husband and wife or parent and child. It’s a theme that permeates much of her work, that sense of isolation coupled with a longing for a little more understanding or a more fulfilling life. I’ve noticed it in several of the novels: A Game of Hide and Seek, At Mrs Lippincote’s and The Soul of Kindness. Probably Mrs Palfrey too, albeit in a different context. And you’re right to highlight Hester Lilly, a wonderful story that illustrates the complexities and confusions of human nature.

  6. clodge2013

    Thanks for this. I like the way you have picked out some of Elizabeth Taylor’s strengths as a writer and illustrated them with the stories from this collection. You have reminded me of how good she is.

    1. JacquiWine Post author

      Thanks, Caroline. I’m glad you liked the post. It’s not too difficult to find examples of Taylor’s insight into human nature – there’s something of real interest on virtually every page. :)

  7. Naomi

    I was at a book sale last weekend (all proceeds going to the Wayward Cat Society – a cause I felt I couldn’t ignore), and Elizabeth Taylor is one of the authors I’ve had my eye out for lately, among others. Still no luck on this front. But I will not give up!

  8. Max Cairnduff

    No surprise that Taylor can write good short fiction. I’ve only read one of her novels so far which I need to correct, so this will have to wait a while. Sounds good though.

    Did you read Kevin Barry’s Dark Lies the Island Jacqui?

    1. JacquiWine Post author

      It is good, but the novels are even better. The titular story is the indisputable star of the show here, partly because the novella-sized length gives Taylor enough scope for some decent character development. Hester and one or two other pieces aside, I would definitely recommend the novels ahead of this collection. They’re just so damn good. I’m trying to think if I can come up with some sort of order of preference for the novels, but I’m struggling a little as they all have their own individual merits. The Soul of Kindness is wonderful — as is A Game of Hide and Seek, the most subtle of the four I’ve read so far. Then again, At Mrs Lippincote’s is terrific too, especially for a debut novel. Whichever one you chose to read next, I doubt you’ll be disappointed.

      No, I haven’t read Dark Lies the Island. In fact I’m not even sure I know very much about it. Did it come to mind for a particular reason?

    1. JacquiWine Post author

      Thanks, Madame Bibi. Her novels are great, aren’t they? So brilliantly observed. The titular story is certainly in that vein, a wonderfully nuanced study of rather complex and compromised character. It’s a real treat.

  9. Caroline

    This sounds marvellous. I have a hige tome with her collected short stories, so I’ll hope to read these soon. She does have a range. I so like the sound of Swan-Moving. It sounds delightful. I was ill all month. I could do with some cheering up.

    1. JacquiWine Post author

      Oh, treat yourself to some comfort reading, that’s bound to do the trick. :)

      I think you’ll love Swan-Moving. It’s a rather touching story – quite tricky to capture in the context of this review as it’s a little different from the other stories in the collection. And Hester Lilly is a real treat, very much in line with her novels – you’re sure to find it of interest.

  10. Elena

    Fab review as usual, Jacqui. You do a terrific job of rescuing women writers and reminding us that there is a lot of work to do there too.

    I have been thinking of lately that I don’t read enough short fiction, and since I am not familiar with Taylor’s work at all this seems like a great place to start. Also, bonus points if I could get my hands on a vintage edition like yours.

    1. JacquiWine Post author

      Thanks, Elena. It’s not hard to get enthusiastic about Taylor as she’s such a wonderful writer, in a class of her own in many respects. There are some great stories here, particularly the pieces I’ve highlighted above (Hester Lilly is a standout). Even so, if you do want to give her a try I would be tempted to suggest one of the novels as a starting point. Something like Mrs Palfrey at the Claremont or At Mrs Lippincote’s – I think they’d give you a better feel for her style. :)

  11. Pingback: A-Z Index of Book Reviews (listed by author) | JacquiWine's Journal

  12. Pingback: My Reading List for The Classics Club | JacquiWine's Journal

  13. Pingback: You’ll Enjoy it When You Get There by Elizabeth Taylor – stories from The Blush | JacquiWine's Journal

  14. Pingback: A Dedicated Man by Elizabeth Taylor | JacquiWine's Journal

  15. Pingback: Wave Me Goodbye, Stories of the Second World War, Part 1 – Jean Rhys, Elizabeth Taylor, Rose Macaulay and more. | JacquiWine's Journal

  16. Pingback: The #1954Club – some reading recommendations for next week | JacquiWine's Journal

Leave a comment or reply - I'd love to hear your thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.