Murder by the Book – Mysteries for Bibliophiles

It’s always a pleasure when one of these British Library Crime Classics anthologies drops through the door, especially in this instance given its literary focus! Murder by the Book is a collection of sixteen short stories that qualify for the genre of ‘bibliomysteries’. More specifically, each of these stories revolves around something bookish. For instance, a mystery featuring a book or someone who works in the book trade – a writer, bookseller, publisher or librarian, perhaps. Alternatively, the crime might take place in a bookish location such as a library or bookshop. All of these permutations are valid, and many of them are showcased in this entertaining collection.

As ever with these anthologies, some entries are stronger than others, so I’ll focus on some of my favourites for this review. Luckily, there are several very enjoyable stories here, more than enough to keep lovers of vintage mysteries interested and engaged. There’s also a good mix of well-known writers – E. C. Bentley, A. A. Milne, Edmund Crispin and Ngaio Marsh – and less familiar names – Philip MacDonald, Roy Vickers and Marjorie Bremner. In fact, some of my favourite stories were written by *new* authors (i.e. new to me), which came as a very pleasant surprise. 

Some of the best stories in this anthology feature crime writers, perhaps unsurprisingly given their penchant for crafting mysteries. In A Lesson in Crime, by husband-and-wife-team GDH and M. Cole, a rather self-satisfied but sloppy crime writer gets a taste of his own medicine when a stranger starts chatting to him during a train journey to Cornwall.

“Now in that book,” the stranger went on, “you call the heroine Elinor and Gertrude on different pages. You cannot make up your mind whether her name was Robbins with two b’s or with one. You have killed the corpse in one place on Sunday and in another on Monday evening. That corpse was discovered twelve hours after the murder still wallowing in a pool of wet blood… (p. 19)

While it’s relatively easy to work out where this one is heading, the premise and the quality of the writing make it a pleasure to read.

Crime writers also feature in Victor Canning’s excellent story A Question of Character, which opens as follows:

The real reason why Geoffrey Gilroy decided to murder his wife was not just that he wished to marry another woman with whom he had fallen in love. No, that may be the kind of motive which forces a man to the point of thinking about murder. But to take him over the edge into action it needs more than that. Plenty of men would like to murder their wives—and the other way round, I suppose. But that so far as it gets. No, the thing which determined Gilroy was his vanity. (p. 227)

Geoffrey Gilroy and his wife Martha are both crime writers. However, in recent years, Martha’s success has outstripped her husband’s, leaving Geoffrey feeling eclipsed by his wife and her skills with characterisation. While Geoffrey has always had a talent for plotting and building suspense, his insights into character leave something to be desired…

As Geoffrey sets about plotting the perfect murder, we see his strengths and weaknesses as a crime writer being laid out before us. It’s a very cleverly crafted story that dovetails beautifully with these characters’ personalities. A wonderfully gripping tale that reminds me a little of Patricia Highsmith and her talent for domestic noir.

Philip MacDonald’s Domestic Malice is another excellent story in this vein, also featuring an author as the central figure in the action. When the writer Carl Borden experiences severe stomach pains, his close friend Dr Wingate begins to suspect that something rather sinister is wrong. Carl has been married to his wife, Annette, for nine years, and although the couple seemed happy at first, their recent behaviour suggests a more troubled or unsettled relationship.

This is one of those stories where you think you’ve got it all worked out, only for the writer to drop in a sudden volte-face at the end of the narrative to catch you off-guard. A devilishly clever story with a real sting in its tail.

In a slight variation on the mysteries-featuring-writers theme, Marjorie Bremner’s Murder in Advance has a playwright as the murder victim, a man with no known enemies or competitors. At first, Inspector Dacre is puzzled by the apparent lack of motive, but the reason for the killing ultimately emerges. It seems the playwright had been planning to expose a blackmailer by writing a play about his crime; however, before the script could be written, the blackmailer murdered the playwright to avoid a scandal. But who is the blackmailer/murderer? That’s what Inspector Dacre must work out…

I also really enjoyed Edmund Crispin’s We Know You’re Busy Writing… in which a freelance writer struggles to get any work done due to the continual stream of interruptions from callers and timewasters. It’s a brilliant little story that will likely resonate with anyone who has ever worked from home, particularly on a freelance basis.  

Other mysteries hinge on clues that appear in particular books. E. C. Bentley’s Trent and the Ministering Angel is a great example of this – an excellent story in which the victim leaves clues to the identity of his murderer in his rock garden, firm in the knowledge that one of his solicitors will link them to the relevant books. Julian Symons’ The Clue in the Book is another enjoyable tale that uses a similar device.

Also of note here is Roy Vickers’ terrific mystery, A Man and his Mother-in-Law, in which a rather selfish man, Arthur Penfold, decides to get rid of his wife’s former guardian, Mrs Blagrove, to avoid any disruption to his cosy life. (Penfold’s dutiful wife, Margaret, is about to leave him to go and live with Mrs B. as she is now in need of constant care.) Again, this is a really compelling story where we know the culprit’s identity upfront – the enjoyment, however, is more in the telling, particularly when Penfold slips up.

In summary, this is another delightful anthology from the British Library, ideal for armchair sleuths with an interest in all things bookish. As ever, the collection comes with an excellent introduction by Martin Edwards, who also provides helpful background notes on each writer. My thanks to the publishers for kindly providing a review copy. (If you’d like to buy a copy of the book, you can do so here via

27 thoughts on “Murder by the Book – Mysteries for Bibliophiles

  1. gertloveday

    These sound great fun. It is most enjoyable to have a break from long form fiction and read short stories, especially when they are as good as these. I am definitely heading that way over the summer.

    1. JacquiWine Post author

      Yes indeed. This type of anthology is a great way of road testing some *new* authors to see how you get on – and if you’re not enjoying a particular story, there’s bound to be a more interesting one coming up in a few minutes.

    1. JacquiWine Post author

      Let me see…looking back at my notes, I’d say there were 5 stories that didn’t particularly grab me for various reasons. All the rest were very good/clever/interesting in some way – in other words they were very enjoyable and sufficiently engaging to maintain my interest. I hope that helps!

  2. heavenali

    So glad you enjoyed these too Jacqui, I thought this was great. Such a good collection of writers, several previously unknown to me, as well as several very familiar names. I loved A Question of Character and The Man and his mother-in-law in particular, both stories have really stayed with me.

    1. JacquiWine Post author

      Yes, I loved those two. In fact there’s a touch of Patricia Highsmith about both of them, and possibly Domestic Malice as well. A very interesting collection all told – and like you, I feel I’ve ‘discovered’ some new writers to explore.

  3. kaggsysbookishramblings

    A great collection, isn’t it? I find that the anthologies from the BL are often my favourites as I do love the variety. The theme here was a good one, and a wonderful selection of authors. As you say, discovering new authors to explore is always fun, and I must admit I thought of you when I read “Domestic Malice” as I thought it would be right up your street!!

    1. JacquiWine Post author

      Ha! Yes, two or three of these stories reminded me a little of Patricia Highsmith, and Domestic Malic was certainly one of them. As you say, the BLCC anthologies always have something interesting to offer – I couldn’t help but think of you when I saw E. C. Bently’s name in the index!

  4. 1streading

    This sounds very entertaining. If writers are going to write about writers I’d prefer if they had a bit of fun doing so! (It also feels like it would very enjoyable to edit in the first place).

    1. JacquiWine Post author

      Yes, indeed. I’m sure Martin Edwards also had a lot of fun putting this collection together, searching for appropriate stories, compiling the accompanying notes and writing the introduction. It feels like a labour of love.

  5. Julé Cunningham

    This is the BL title I’m probably most looking forward to Poisoned Pen Press getting around to publishing, though still don’t see it listed yet. It would have made for a lovely Christmas read too.

    1. JacquiWine Post author

      Oh, it feels like a missed opportunity if doesn’t get published till next year! As you say, it’s ideal for Christmas – both gifting and reading. Even though the quality always varies somewhat from story to story in these anthologies, the best ones in this selection are very good indeed. All in all, a most entertaining read.

  6. Pingback: A-Z Index of Book Reviews (listed by author) | JacquiWine's Journal

    1. JacquiWine Post author

      Yes – and funnily enough, it was the stories by less familiar writers that I enjoyed the most. With the exception of Crispin and Bentley, all the other authors I’ve highlighted above were completely new to me, so the quality of their stories was a very pleasant surprise!


Leave a comment or reply - I'd love to hear your thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.